Proposal for the LCMS Vicarage and Pastoral Support Initiative (VPSI)

Revitalizing Ministry: A Strategic Path to Address the LCMS Pastor Shortage and Foster Sustainable Growth

Executive Summary

The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (LCMS) is grappling with a potentially insurmountable demographic crisis that is masking the truth about the Synod’s “pastor shortage”. Empty pulpits are a cumulating crisis of attendance, congregational capacity, and funding driven by the 50% decline in membership and attendance over the past quarter of a century. Many congregations cannot afford pastors, and the time has come for a radical reorientation toward an intentional recovery and sustainability strategy. It will require mergers for unviable churches and strategic growth through new church plants that deviate from past assumed best practices.

This proposal for the LCMS Vicarage and Pastoral Support Initiative (VPSI) seeks to raise $120 million to place 100 pastors in high-need viable congregations and new plants over a 10-year ramp-up, with financial support tied to accountability measures. Funds will include strings attached: unviable recipient congregations must commit to merging or other rationalization strategies.

At least one-third of placements will target new church plants in underserved areas outside the Midwest to foster expansion and vitality. The Initiative also reforms vicarage assignments by compensating host congregations $50,000 annually and shifting to a merit-based grant system that has congregations competing for vicars.

Funding sources: $40 million from the Synod, $20 million each from Concordia Theological Seminary (CTS) and Concordia Seminary, St. Louis (CSL), $20 million from Concordia Publishing House (CPH), and $20 million from grant applications and targeted fundraising. Additional proceeds from congregational consolidations (asset sales) are projected at $5 million over 10 years, ramped proportionally to new pastor placements (therefore, receipts are back-loaded as placements increase). By Year 10, the program reaches full capacity, followed by a thorough evaluation for ongoing viability. Successful congregations are weaned off support and become self-sustaining, directing available resources to further consolidation and emerging needs.

To address inflation, all financial supports (pastor salaries, capacity-building grants, and vicar payments) have been projected to increase annually based on the 10-year historical mean U.S. inflation rate of 2.86% (calculated from annual CPI percent changes for 2015–2024).

Introduction and Background

The LCMS has experienced a profound shift in its demographic and unity trends that threatens to engulf the Synod and drive it to involuntary liquidation. Membership and average weekly attendance have fallen approximately 50% over the last 25 years (from around 800,000 in real weekly attendance circa 2000 to less than 400,000 in 2025, based on adjusted figures accounting for record-keeping and reporting discrepancies). This decline has created a so-called “pastor shortage” that is fundamentally a shortfall in congregational capacity and funding.

Smaller, struggling churches (often in rural or inner urban areas) increasingly lack the resources to support full-time pastors, maintain their facilities, or conduct business competently. That generates long-term vacancies with part-time arrangements for Word and Sacrament Ministry, or outright closures. The traditional pastoral call and assignment processes exacerbate this, inadvertently favoring financially stable congregations.

The change is most radical because it prioritizes financial incentives with accountability; an unusual concept for the LCMS if we are honest. Funds come with strings: Congregations deemed unviable (e.g., based on sustained low attendance, negative financial trends, lack of growth potential, or facilities beyond rehabilitation) must agree to merge with nearby churches (40 minute drive radius as a starting point) or undergo rationalization (e.g., becoming mission outposts) as a condition of receiving support. This ensures resources are used efficiently and promotes healthier, consolidated ministries fit for the LCMS’s current life cycle.

Additionally, to counter geographic concentration in the Midwest (states like Missouri, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin), at least one-third of pastoral placements will support new church plants in underserved regions such as the West Coast, South, Southwest, Southeast, Northeast, and other areas with low LCMS presence but high mission potential.

Rooted in the non-negotiable need for maintaining orthodox Word and Sacrament ministry, this Initiative will transform vicarage and pastoral calls/assignments into a core of intentional “champion” congregations that can build self-sustaining operations and become net contributors to the next cycle.

Objectives

• Address Capacity Shortfalls: Provide targeted support to congregations unable to afford pastors, while enforcing sustainability through mergers or rationalization for unviable ones.

• Promote Strategic Growth: Dedicate at least one-third of placements to new church plants outside the Midwest to expand the LCMS footprint in underserved areas, especially those that are culturally adjacent.

• Reform Vicarage Assignments: Shift to a merit-based grant application system that compensates host congregations and deliberately cultivates high-quality “teaching congregations” in the manner of a medical residency program.

• Enhance Sustainability: Offer capacity-building grants and 10-year funding to foster self-sufficiency, with regular evaluations ensuring long-term viability.

• Ramp Up and Evaluate: Scale gradually to full capacity by Year 10, assessing outcomes regularly to determine continuation, adaptation, or termination.

Program Components

Pastor Placement Program

Pastoral Calls and Placements will prioritize congregations and new plants most in need, selected via applications reviewed by a joint committee (Synod, seminaries, district presidents, and the VPSI Board of Directors). Criteria include financial need, mission potential, and layers of viability assessments. At least one-third (from year 5) will be new church plants outside the Midwest, allocated proportionally each year (e.g., focusing on areas with growing populations but limited LCMS presence, such as urban centers in key cities, Texas border regions, the I-5 Corridor, Appalachia, and the Baptist Bible Belt).

• Placement Structure:

  • New pastors placed annually: 2 in Year 1, 4 in Year 2, 6 in Year 3, 8 in Year 4, 10 in Year 5, 10 in Year 6, 12 in Year 7, 14 in Year 8, 16 in Year 9, and 18 in Year 10, building to 100 active by Year 10.

    • The Initiative resides with the church and does not follow the pastor if he resigns a call.

  • Pastor Sources: 40% from current pastors not older than 45 at the start of their term, 60% from seminary graduates, allocated proportionally each year to balance experience with fresh talent.

  • 10-year term per placement; congregations must demonstrate progress toward self-sufficiency to retain the full grant program.

• Strings Attached:

  • Unviable congregations (defined by metrics like average attendance below 50, persistent deficits, or no growth in 5+ years) must sign agreements to merge or rationalize within 5-10 years, facilitated by district support. The VPSI Board of Directors would apply asset sales directly to the supported church and direct any surpluses to the VPSI Endowment.

  • New plants receive startup guidance and must track reasonably to defined performance metrics to retain funding.

• Financial Support:

  • Salary: $80,000 per year for the first three years of each pastor’s placement, then $100,000 per year for years 4-10, adjusted annually for inflation.

    • The congregation is responsible for funding Health insurance, life and disability insurance, retirement benefits, travel expenses, and housing allowance.

  • Parsonage Rehabilitation Bonus: $20,000 per new pastor in the first year of their placement (not adjusted for inflation; only applies to congregations with a parsonage).

  • Capacity-Building Grant: $10,000 annually per congregation to achieve and maintain administrative excellence for payroll, benefits, insurance, etc.; any unused amount may be applied to building maintenance and other needs, adjusted annually for inflation. The Synod should look for centralized solutions to reduce costs for accounting, benefits management, property and casualty insurance, and other related services.

This approach ensures accountability while being alert to the risk of congregations becoming welfare dependent.

Vicarage Assignment Program

Congregations apply to host ~100 vicars annually, which carries a $50,000 grant to the hosts (adjusted annually for inflation) to pay the vicar. Priority is given to parishes demonstrating clear leadership in practical theology and following a more defined vicarage “curriculum” designed by the practical theology experts at each seminary.

Vicarages will be capped at 100 per year, effectively setting the maximum class size for each year, which will also address the current oversupply of pastors (the Synod has seen no material change in the number of rostered pastors despite the collapse in membership and attendance - there were 5,323 active pastors in 2004 and 5,574 in 2023).

Economic Structure

Expenses ramp up with placements. To account for inflation, all support amounts (pastor salaries, capacity grants, and vicar payments) are projected to increase annually at the 10-year historical mean U.S. inflation rate of 2.86%, based on CPI data from 2015 to 2024.

Notes on Economics:

• Pastor salaries are calculated per cohort, starting at $80,000 (adjusted for inflation) for the first three years of each pastor’s tenure, increasing to $100,000 (adjusted) thereafter.

• Capacity grants and vicar payments follow the inflation adjustment (e.g., vicar payment ~$51,430 in Year 2, up to ~$64,400 in Year 10).

• Bonuses are $20,000 per new pastor in their placement year, fixed (not adjusted for inflation).

• Active pastors are cumulative placements.

• Proceeds from congregational consolidations (asset sales) are projected at $5 million total over 10 years, allocated proportionally to new placements each year ($0.1M in Year 1, $0.2M in Year 2, $0.3M in Year 3, $0.4M in Year 4, $0.5M in Year 5, $0.5M in Year 6, $0.6M in Year 7, $0.7M in Year 8, $0.8M in Year 9, $0.9M in Year 10) and added to the endowment at the end of each year.

• Total projected program cost: $107.58 million over 10 years. The initial $120 million fund could be invested (e.g., in a conservative endowment yielding ~5% annually) to cover expenses and provide a buffer for contingencies.

• Post-Year 10: If viable, maintain placements to sustain 100 active (adjusting for roll-offs), with costs stabilizing around $20-25M/year (inflation-adjusted), funded by returns or renewed contributions.

• Administrative overhead is 3% for years 1-6 and 2% for years 7-10, added to the annual program costs to form the total withdrawals.

Funding Sources

The Initiative will raise $120 million through directed contributions from LCMS entities and external grants:

• LCMS Office of National Mission: $40 million (33.3%).

• Concordia Theological Seminary (CTS): $20 million (16.7%).

• Concordia Seminary (CSL): $20 million (16.7%)

• Concordia Publishing House (CPH): $20 million (16.7%), reflecting a commitment to return profits to the congregations instead of making distributions to the Synod.

• Grants: $20 million (16.7%), as an external grant to bolster pastoral initiatives.

Additionally, asset sales from congregational consolidations will contribute an estimated $5 million over 10 years to be reinvested in the endowment.

Implementation Timeline

• Year 0 (2028): Establish administration and governance, secure funds, define viability criteria, pilot (e.g., two pastors, including at least one new plant; 20 vicars). Funded entirely from ONM funds and not drawing from the VPSI Endowment.

• Years 1-10 (from 2029): Annual placements with monitoring; impose merger agreements as needed.

• Annual Reviews: Track progress, including new plant growth, rationalization outcomes, inflation adjustments, and persistent pitfalls and problems.

• Year 10 Evaluation: Audit sustainability (e.g., 80% of congregations self-funding pastors post-support).

Evaluation and Sustainability

Metrics will include merger and rationalization success rates, new plant viability (e.g., attendance growth), reversal in membership and attendance decline trends, and regional diversification. If viable, continue for new initiatives; otherwise, redirect funds.

Endowment Balance Projection

To model the $120 million endowment’s performance over 10 years, assuming an annual return of approximately 5% (compounded annually on the beginning-of-year balance and added before the year’s withdrawal), and using the inflation-adjusted yearly withdrawals from the economic structure table (totaling $107.58 million over 10 years, plus administrative overhead to form total withdrawals of $110.19 million), the following table details the yearly progression.

Notes:

• Total investment income over 10 years: approximately $55.94 million.

• Total withdrawals: $110.19 million (including administrative overhead).

• Total proceeds from asset sales: $5 million.

• Net result: Starting at $120 million, after adding investment income and proceeds while subtracting withdrawals, the endowment would have approximately $70.75 million remaining after Year 10. This provides a substantial buffer for ongoing operations or extensions if the program proves viable.

Conclusion

By confronting the funding, capacity, and demographic crisis head-on with accountable support and targeted growth, the VPSI offers the LCMS a path to recovery and resuming organic growth.

Incorporating inflation adjustments ensures the Initiative’s financial supports retain value, with projected pastor salaries starting at $80,000 per pastor (rising with inflation and stepping up to a $100,000 base after three years of each pastor’s tenure). The parsonage rehabilitation bonus adds targeted support for new placements each year and incentivizes congregations not to sell or neglect housing for their pastors.

With the addition of 20 million in grants (e.g. Lilly, Schwann) to the initial endowment (totaling $120 million), $5 million in projected proceeds from consolidations, reduced administrative overhead to 2% after Year 6, and a balanced mix of pastor sources (40% current pastors ≤45, 60% seminary graduates), total costs are $110.19 million over 10 years. Yet, the endowment model leaves a substantial buffer of approximately $70.75 million, demonstrating enhanced fiscal viability.

This Initiative demands rapid and bold action from LCMS leadership to implement as soon as possible to address the Synod’s ongoing slow-motion collapse.

---

SWOT Analysis of the LCMS Vicarage and Pastoral Support Initiative (VPSI)

Strengths (Internal Advantages)

• Robust Funding and Sustainability Model: The $120 million endowment, including $20 million in grants and $5 million in projected proceeds from asset sales, provides a strong financial base with projected investment returns (~5% annually), leaving ~$70.75 million after 10 years, ensuring long-term viability without immediate reliance on ongoing donations.

• Targeted Support for High-Need Areas: By prioritizing underserved congregations, new church plants (at least one-third outside the Midwest), and including parsonage rehabilitation bonuses ($20,000 per new pastor), the Initiative directly tackles financial barriers, fostering growth in viable areas while incentivizing mergers for unviable ones.

• Reforms to Vicarage and Placement Processes: Shifting from the current ‘bidding’ to a rigorous grant-application system with $50,000 host congregation compensation (inflation-adjusted) promotes improved vicar training, more standardization in field work outcomes, and higher pastoral retention.

• Inflation-Adjusted and Phased Salary Structure: Starting salaries at $80,000 for the first three years per pastor (stepping to $100,000 thereafter, adjusted at 2.86% annually) balance affordability with attractiveness, while capacity-building grants ($10,000/year) enhance congregational operations. Salaries will be above district scale in nearly every case, creating incentives for excellence and endurance at every level.

• Accountability Mechanisms and Diverse Pastor Pool: “Strings attached” (e.g., required mergers for unviable churches) ensure efficient resource use, aligning with goals of sustainability and mission focus. Sourcing 40% of placements from current pastors ≤45 years old and 60% from seminary graduates blends experience with fresh perspectives, aiding retention and innovation.

Weaknesses (Internal Disadvantages)

• High Upfront and Operational Costs: Total projected program costs of $107.58 million over 10 years, plus administrative overhead (3% initially, reducing to 2% after Year 6), could strain resources if investment returns underperform, inflation exceeds projections, or asset sale proceeds fall short of $5 million.

• Slow Ramp-Up and Scale Limitations: Starting with only two placements in Year 1 and reaching 100 by Year 10 may not address immediate vacancies quickly enough, especially given debates on whether the “shortage” is truly about pastor numbers or congregational affordability.

• Dependency on External Funding and Assumptions: Reliance on grants, specific entities (Synod, seminaries, CPH), and back-loaded asset sales introduces risks if contributions or sales (tied to consolidations) fall short; economic projections assume consistent 2.86% inflation and 5% returns, which may not hold.

• Implementation Challenges: Enforcing mergers or rationalization could face internal resistance from congregations, and the cohort-based salary structure (per-pastor adjustments) adds administrative complexity. Sourcing 40% from younger current pastors may limit options if availability and/or quality is low.

• Limited Scope Relative to Decline: Supporting only 100 pastors may be insufficient against a backdrop of 45% of congregations having <50 weekly attendance, potentially requiring broader systemic changes.

• Seminary Resistance: The seminaries may be resistant to capping annual cohorts to a total of 100 students.

• Factional Resistance: Factions resistant to centralized capacity development may seek to sabotage VPSI.

Opportunities (External Advantages)

• Capitalize on Membership Trends for Renewal: With LCMS membership declining ~50% over 25 years (e.g., weekly attendance from ~800,000 in 2000 to ~<400,000 in 2025), the Initiative can drive consolidation of small churches and expansion into growing regions, potentially reversing projections of the Synod’s effective “orderly extinction” by the middle of this century.

• Synergies with Broader Recruitment Efforts: Aligns with LCMS initiatives like “Set Apart to Serve” for church worker recruitment, offering a platform to encourage more men into ministry at a time when the difficulties of being a career pastor seem insurmountable. The mix of 60% seminary graduates and 40% younger current pastors could boost recruitment pipelines.

• External Partnerships and Grants: Grant funding of clergy development could lead to additional grants and ongoing efforts to enhance pastoral formation.

• Geographic and Demographic Expansion: Focusing on new plants outside the Midwest (where 58% of members reside) taps into underserved U.S. regions with population growth, potentially attracting younger demographics and countering aging clergy issues.

• Public Sentiment and Recruitment Momentum: Social media discussions show enthusiasm for recruitment challenges and critiques of the “shortage,” providing a chance to mobilize LCMS members for support and participation.

Threats (External Disadvantages)

• Persistent Membership and Attendance Decline: Ongoing drops (e.g., congregations down from 6,000 to 5,700, 25% with <25 weekly attendees) could exacerbate the perceived shortage, outpacing the Initiative’s scale and leading to more vacancies or closures.

• Debates and Fragmentation on Pastor Shortage: Skepticism that the “shortage” is illusory (due to unaffordable congregations rather than pastor numbers) might erode support; unauthorized alternative ordination programs could threaten coherent certified pastoral formation and sending.

• Economic and Market Risks: Higher-than-assumed inflation, investment losses, or economic downturns could deplete the endowment faster; broader U.S. trends like aging clergy and delayed retirements add pressure, potentially impacting the availability of current pastors ≤45 for 40% of placements.

• Internal and Cultural Resistance: Risks of division over seminary reforms or “bureaucratic” priorities, including resistance to consolidations that are critical for the Initiative.

• Competition from Alternative Models: Proposals for shorter training or independent seminaries could draw resources away, while demographic factors (e.g., fewer children in LCMS families) threaten long-term sustainability.

☩TW☩