7 Comments
User's avatar
Rev. Dr. David H. Benke's avatar

Waiting for publication!

Expand full comment
Martin's avatar

Gotta love Our Lady!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 3, 2025
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Martin's avatar

Simply referring to Mary as "Our Lady", is not putting her into the same category as Our Lord, Jesus Christ. For starters, Christ Himself referred to her as simply "Woman" (John 2:4) as in- the Woman prophesied in Genesis to crush the head of Satan through her seed. If Christ at the Wedding in Cana was okay with giving her such a "grandiose" title that singled her out as a special, unique woman, then we Christians can take His lead on that. After all, she's a totally unique woman who is "clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and on her head a crown of 12 stars. (Revelation 12:1). Singling her out is ok, because Christ, Heaven, and Sacred Scripture clearly do the same.

Secondly, good thing that I'm a Catholic and not Protestant, so your concern doesn't apply to me. There's no such thing as Mariolotry. This is a misunderstanding of what Catholics do. We adore and worship God in the Unbloody Representation of Christ's Holy Sacrifice at the Mass. What is given to Mary is "hyper dulia"- it's a higher form of veneration than any other holy man or woman receives, but it is NOT worship. Catholics, more than anyone else, understand that sacrifice and worship are for the Blessed Trinity alone. They are never offered to Our Lady. I invite you to examine what you view as worship and compare it to what Catholics claim is their form of worship- it's probably vastly different.

Thirdly, let's not worry about giving Mary too much honor and respect- that's just a sin of pride. St. Maximilian Kolbe put it best when he said, "Never be afraid of loving the Blessed Virgin too much. You can never love her more than Jesus did."

I can recommend some further reading for you to look into Marian DEVOTION- not worship- and see that it ultimately draws us closer to Christ. We as Christians are called to make ourselves as Christ-like as possible. Maybe entrust yourself to the only woman who could claim that she formed the Body of Christ in her womb.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 4, 2025
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Martin's avatar

You're Lutheran, so you follow a religion started by Martin Luther.... The guy who publicly claimed that he had a devotion to Our Lady. . . The only one showing any offense to Lutheran teaching in this case is you.

Your ignorance of Scripture and typology is quite apparent from your post. I could give you a list of early Church Fathers who drew a connection between Cana and Genesis 3. For now, I'll leave it at the bare minimum- Woman, as it was spoken by Christ, is the same word that was used to name Eve. In Hebrew/Aramaic, they're the same word. So, Christ makes that connection explicit. Also, did Eve give birth to the seed that crushes the head of Satan? Cain, Abel, Seth.... No, they didn't do that. It was Mary that gave birth to Christ.

The woman of Revelation 12 has multiple meanings, which includes Mary, just like the dragon not only represents Satan but also sin, evil, the persecutors of the Christians, etc. Again, clearly the woman also represents Our Lady because she, in verse 5, gives birth to "a male child, destined to rule the nations with an iron rod" (Revelation 12:5). That's clearly an allusion to Psalm 2, which is a prophecy of the Messiah.

Now, how many women in Scripture give birth to the Messiah that's destined to rule all the nations? I can only think of one! It's Mary. "Our Lady" if you will.

The difference being "bogus" in your opinion is just that- your opinion. Quite measly compared to Sacred Scriptures and Church Tradition.

Lastly, we know from Revelation 12, which we now know alludes to Our Lady, that Mary is in Heaven. Christ Himself said that God is "the God of the living, not the dead" (Matthew 22:32). We pray to someone who is very much alive. And according to Scripture, again Revelation 12, she's a queen- crowned with stars! Clearly, Christ viewed her as doing some pretty remarkable things in her life.

It's not worship to ask someone to pray for you or do you a favor. Worship involves sacrifice, something that Catholics exclusively offer to the Trinity. It's not splitting hairs, because it is the sacrifice of Christ that is represented at the Mass- hardly a small matter or a case of "splitting hairs". We would never offer that to Our Lady.

I recommend more study of Scripture and Church History. You'll gain a worthy, wonderful intercessor in Mary by doing so. Sorry for stepping on your toes by interacting with a Lutheran post. I saw a post about my mother and got enthusiastic enough to comment.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 4, 2025
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Martin's avatar

By directly addressing my comment in a way that was also directed towards me?

I can tell that you have no better arguments because you're resorting to a low-hanging fruit insult. Maybe chew on the Scriptural references that I gave you- they'll take you a lot further than relying on your own opinion and one-liners.

Expand full comment